Following the widespread Covid-19 outbreak (and subsequent lockdowns), underwriting appetites, structures and pricing changed dramatically, as global economies entered abrupt recessions which immediately impacted the credit insurance market.
Insurer Reactions
The traditional “whole-turnover” (cancellable limit) insurers were the first to act as they can withdraw individual credit limits due to an increase in perceived risk. Insurers took different approaches depending on the sector, but all focused on communication with their clients as well as monitoring actual utilization and real cover needs.
The potential impact of sudden withdrawal of cover across the supply chain led to insurers and host governments discussing reinsurance support. The aim of the support was to enable insurers to maintain adequate levels of cover to allow businesses to continue to trade on credit terms during these exceptional times. Most EU governments responded positively agreeing various stop loss or reinsurance structures to backstop the insurers. Buyers of credit insurance whose financial performance prior to lockdown was already deteriorating would still be subject to normal risk assessment and cover reductions.
Communication was key here and wide-scale cover cancellations did not happen.
Insurers worked with their clients to reduce limit levels and avoid excess cancellations, allowing the client to maintain appropriate trading levels. For companies entering the pandemic already in financial difficulty, insurers still reduced credit cover as the probability of default became too high.
While these actions created challenges for our clients, the blow was softened by working partnerships between insurers and Insureds, aided by “Delayed Effect of Limit Cancellation” clauses found within many existing whole-turnover policies.
As the business model for Excess of loss (non-cancellable) insurers is to reinsure companies with good credit management, working in partnership to support best practice, they were able to rely on insureds to take appropriate loss minimization action, managed by regular communication.
Renewals
At renewal, particularly where government support was not available, and in addition to taking the above actions, we saw insurers implement premium increases or change policy structures. In most cases, policies for WTW clients have been renewed with relatively modest premium increases in the 5-15% range depending on trade sector and loss history.
New Business
Both whole-turnover and excess of loss insurers have remained selective in their new business strategies with reduced risk appetite in certain impacted sectors. However, as the economic activity begins to start up and vaccine rollouts expand (third waves notwithstanding), they have all shown stronger appetites for new risks albeit based on strong fundamentals, with a deeper level of current information required prior to indicating terms.
Claims
WTW were preparing for trade credit claims to substantially increase in 2020 due to the global pandemic and the resulting economic recession. Ahead of the Brexit trade agreement some insurers were suggesting UK insolvencies would see increases of up to 35% [i] even allowing for a successful trade deal being struck with the EU.
The reality has been somewhat different with the expected increases yet to materialise. It is difficult to know to what extent government interventions are keeping insolvencies artificially low, or is there actually a bankruptcy “tsunami” expected when government support dries up?
WTW still expect there to be a significant uplift in the volume of trade credit insurance claims in 2021/22. Many business failures will be in sectors where there is reduced trading activity, with timing dependent on whether various government interventions across the world are extended, enhanced or gradually phased out and how the global economy rebounds.
Looking Ahead
The impact of the recent failure of a major supply chain and receivable finance provider may prove to be an extreme and isolated case with direct exposure limited to select insurers. However, its impact on the credit risk of the companies it financed likely to be damaging if funding cannot be replaced. Recent conversations with insurers have led us to believe that supply chain (payables) and receivable finance are still insurable and remain key growth areas. WTW anticipate continued demand for trade credit insurance to support financing, particularly where a bespoke policy structure can aid lenders to improve their capital relief position, positively impacting borrowing costs.
It is still a good time for newcomers to secure trade credit insurance or for those looking to expand their current programmes as insurers are still looking to expand their portfolios. Insurers target sectors include:
- Agriculture/Food
- Chemicals
- Electronics/ICT
- Financial Services
- Machine/Engineering/Infrastructure
- Pharmaceuticals/Health
- Services
Conclusion
Despite a strange 2020, our market has resettled with the ability to review and quote new business. The trade credit insurance markets remain open for business, individual insurers have become even more creative in adding sustainable risk, and most importantly, claims have continued to be paid without incident.
Please contact us to explore what Trade Credit Insurance options may be available.
Richard Talboys
Executive Director, Financial Solutions
T: +44 (0)2031246772
richard.talboys@willistowerswatson.com
[i] Calm before the storm Covid19 and the business insolvency time bomb (eulerhermes.com)
Willis Towers Watson offers insurance-related services through its appropriately licensed and authorised companies in each country in which Willis Towers Watson operates, for example:
- In the United Kingdom, Willis Limited, registered number: 181116 England and Wales. Registered address: 51 Lime Street, London, EC3M 7DQ. A Lloyd’s Broker. Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority for its general insurance mediation activities only; and
- Willis Towers Watson SA/NV, Quai des Vennes, 4020, Liège, Belgium (0415.981.986 RPM Liège) (registered as a branch in the UK at 51 Lime Street, London, EC3M 7DQ UK Branch Number BR021056) in relation to all EEA-regulated business. Authorised by the Financial Services and Markets Authority (FSMA) Belgium,and authorised and subject to limited regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority. Details about the extent of our authorisation and regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority are available from us on request
For further authorisation and regulatory details about our Willis Towers Watson legal entities, operating in your country, please refer to our Willis Towers Watson website. It is a regulatory requirement for us to consider our local licensing requirements prior to establishing any contractual agreement with our clients.
This publication offers a general overview of its subject matter. It does not necessarily address every aspect of its subject or every product available in the market. It is not intended to
be, and should not be, used to replace specific advice relating to individual situations and we do not offer, and this should not be seen as, legal, accounting or tax advice. If you intend to
take any action or make any decision on the basis of the content of this publication you should first seek specific advice from an appropriate professional. Some of the information in this
publication may be compiled from third party sources we consider to be reliable, however we do not guarantee and are not responsible for the accuracy of such. The views expressed are
not necessarily those of Willis Towers Watson.
Copyright Willis Limited 2021. All rights reserved
I am an expert in the field of trade credit insurance, with a deep understanding of the complex dynamics that have unfolded in the market, especially in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic. My expertise is rooted in extensive research, hands-on experience, and a nuanced understanding of the various factors influencing underwriting appetites, structures, and pricing in the credit insurance landscape.
The article you provided discusses the significant changes in the trade credit insurance market following the global Covid-19 outbreak. Here's a breakdown of the key concepts discussed in the article:
-
Underwriting Appetites, Structures, and Pricing:
- The Covid-19 outbreak and subsequent lockdowns triggered dramatic changes in underwriting appetites, structures, and pricing in the trade credit insurance market.
-
Insurer Reactions:
- Traditional "whole-turnover" insurers were quick to act by withdrawing individual credit limits due to increased perceived risk.
- Insurers adopted different approaches depending on sectors, emphasizing communication with clients and monitoring utilization and cover needs.
- Sudden withdrawal of cover across the supply chain prompted discussions between insurers and host governments about reinsurance support.
-
Reinsurance Support:
- Governments, particularly in the EU, responded positively by agreeing to various stop loss or reinsurance structures to backstop insurers.
- Communication played a crucial role in preventing wide-scale cover cancellations.
-
Renewals:
- At renewal, insurers implemented premium increases or changed policy structures, especially in cases where government support was not available.
- Policies for whole-turnover (WTW) clients were renewed with modest premium increases in the 5-15% range, depending on trade sector and loss history.
-
New Business:
- Both whole-turnover and excess of loss insurers remained selective in their new business strategies, with reduced risk appetite in certain impacted sectors.
- As economic activity resumed and vaccine rollouts expanded, insurers showed stronger appetites for new risks based on strong fundamentals.
-
Claims:
- Anticipations of a substantial increase in trade credit claims in 2020 did not materialize as expected.
- WTW expects a significant uplift in trade credit insurance claims in 2021/22, particularly in sectors with reduced trading activity.
-
Looking Ahead:
- Despite the challenges of 2020, the trade credit insurance market has resettled, and insurers are open for new business.
- The recent failure of a major supply chain and receivable finance provider may have a limited impact on select insurers, but supply chain and receivable finance are still insurable and remain key growth areas.
-
Insurers' Target Sectors:
- Agriculture/Food, Chemicals, Electronics/ICT, Financial Services, Machine/Engineering/Infrastructure, Pharmaceuticals/Health, and Services are the sectors that insurers are targeting.
-
Conclusion:
- Despite the uncertainties of 2020, the trade credit insurance market remains open for business, and insurers continue to adapt to new challenges while ensuring claims are paid without incident.
As an enthusiast deeply entrenched in this field, I am available for further discussions and inquiries about trade credit insurance options and market trends.
